Athanasios Rantos questions whether compensation to investors constitutes state aid, a key argument for Spain to avoid paying renewable awards.
According to pressdigital.es, the Advocate General of the Court of Justice of the European Union (TJUE), Athanasios Rantos, has issued a non-binding opinion that challenges one of the arguments used by the Spanish Government and the European Commission to delay compliance with arbitration awards. The document was published this Thursday and refers to the Micula case, a procedure related to Romania.
Rantos argues that financially compensating an investor for harm caused by regulatory changes does not automatically equate to an incompatible subsidy with the internal market. He adds that this distinction is also applicable to international arbitration tribunals, according to sources from the creditor funds that acquired the rights of representation and collection against Spain.
The opinion represents a setback for the Executive, which had invoked the jurisprudence of the Micula case to block the payment of nearly thirty rulings related to retroactive cuts to renewable premiums. The outstanding bill amounts to €2.367 billion.
Rantos also dismisses the adhesive cassation appeal presented by Spain, which denied that investors have a legitimate interest to appeal to the community courts against Brussels' decisions that block the execution of their awards.
The same sources believe that the reasoning calls into question the March 2025 decision in which the European Commission prohibited Spain from paying €101 million from the Antin case, as it relies on the Romanian precedent that the Advocate General seeks to annul in his article 1. Furthermore, it casts doubt on the formal investigation that Brussels opened in August against the payment of €32.95 million to the Japanese firm JGC Holdings.
For the creditor funds, the conclusions weaken Spain's position in the seizures and enforcement processes opened in the United States, the United Kingdom, Australia, and Singapore, where the Executive relied on Brussels' prohibition to halt the claims.
The final ruling will now correspond to the judges of the TJUE, who will decide whether one of Spain's main legal arguments for not complying with arbitration awards falls permanently.

