A payment of €23,417.43 instead of €23,417.47 left four cents unpaid and prevented him from benefiting from the 5% surcharge. The case appears in the 2025 Report of the Council for the Defence of the Taxpayer.
A four-cent error in a payment to the Tax Agency has resulted in a surcharge of over €4,000 for a taxpayer. The case, recorded in the 2025 Report of the Council for the Defence of the Taxpayer, as published by Líder Actual, dates back to a declaration from 2023.
The taxpayer was required to submit model 111, which includes the IRPF withholdings for the third quarter of 2023, for a debt of €23,417.47. He did not pay within the deadline nor did he request a deferral or instalment, so the debt moved to the executive period, although the Tax Agency had not yet sent the enforcement notice.
When attempting to settle it, he entered €23,417.43. That difference of four cents prevented the debt from being considered fully paid, meaning he could not benefit from the 5% executive surcharge, which he would have been able to apply if he had paid the full amount before receiving the enforcement notification.
The General Tax Law sets three surcharges depending on the timing of the payment: the 5% executive surcharge, equivalent to €1,170.87 on that debt; the reduced 10% enforcement surcharge of €2,341.75; and the ordinary 20% enforcement surcharge of €4,683.49, which also incurs late interest. The Council notes that the error caused a surcharge of over €4,000, although its report does not specify the final amount demanded.
The affected individual filed a complaint, registered under number 825-2024. The Council acknowledges that the Tax Agency applied the regulations as they are written, but believes that the law does not provide for a margin of tolerance for such small arithmetic differences and that there is a clear disproportion between the four unpaid cents and the economic consequences.
To prevent similar cases, the Council has forwarded a proposal for proportionality criteria to the Secretary of State for Finance and the management of the Tax Agency, applicable when the outstanding amount is minimal and arises from evident arithmetic or material errors. As a reference, it suggests a threshold of three euros that already exists in some procedures for cancelling small debts.
The agency also compares the surcharges for submitting a self-assessment late without prior requirement, which range from 1% to 15% depending on the delay, with those for debts in the executive period, which can reach 20%. This is a recommendation directed at the Tax Agency and not an approved legal modification, so for now, the current regulations continue to apply as they are.

